Criminal defense lawyers · New York City, NY
Which New York City criminal defense lawyers does Claude recommend?
We asked Claude 1 question about criminal defense lawyers that a person in New York City might ask, with web search on, the week of Nov 9, 2026. Here is who it named, and how that changed from the week before.
Asked the week of Nov 9, 2026
Who Claude named
The first week we asked, so there is nothing to compare with yet. Ranked by how many answers named them, then by how early.
| # | Business | Named in | Avg. position | vs last week |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Greco Neyland, PCMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 1.0 | first week |
| 2 | Elena FastMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 2.0 | first week |
| 3 | Michael H. JosephMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 3.0 | first week |
| 4 | Laura K. GasiorowskiMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 4.0 | first week |
| 5 | William Vance FerroMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 5.0 | first week |
| 6 | Jeffery L. GrecoMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 6.0 | first week |
| 7 | Robert G. StahlMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 7.0 | first week |
| 8 | Legal Aid SocietyMapfirst week | 1 of 1 answer | 8.0 | first week |
Not on the list?
Is your firm missing from the list?
We help practices and firms get found by Claude, ChatGPT and Google. Book 15 minutes with Zach and we'll look at why the assistants pass you over and what would change it.
Want to know what ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity say about you too? Book 15 minutes and we'll check.
Word for word
The full answers
“Who is the best criminal defense lawyer in New York City?”
There isn't one objectively "best" criminal defense lawyer in NYC. The right choice depends on your charge, whether the case is in state or federal court, and your budget. My search turned up limited, mostly directory-style information, so treat this as a starting point and not a ranking.
Firms that came up with good reviews - Greco Neyland, PC is a firm of former prosecutors with over 25 years of experience and more than 100 jury trials. It handles state and federal matters, with offices in Long Island, Westchester and Manhattan. Its Thumbtack rating is about 4.85 from 91 reviews. - Justia's NYC criminal directory lists several attorneys with 10/10 peer ratings. They include Elena Fast, Michael H. Joseph, Laura K. Gasiorowski, William Vance Ferro, Jeffery L. Greco and Robert G. Stahl. Each has only one or two peer reviews, so that's a thin basis for comparison.
I couldn't confirm the current open status of each practice beyond these active directory listings. Check that before you call.
How to choose - Pick someone who mainly does criminal defense in the court where your case is, such as Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or federal court in the SDNY or EDNY. - Ask how many cases like yours they have taken to trial, and who will actually handle your case. - Check their disciplinary record on the NY court system's attorney lookup, and read Avvo and Google reviews. - Get fee structures in writing. Many offer free or low-cost consultations. - If you can't afford a lawyer, you have the right to one. In NYC, the Legal Aid Society and other public defender organizations are staffed by experienced trial lawyers.
If you tell me the charge and the borough, I can narrow this down.
claude-sonnet-5-5 · asked Nov 10, 2026
How we ask
Method
Once a week we ask Claude (Anthropic's assistant) the same fixed questions a person in each city might type, with web search turned on and set to that city, and we ask it to check the web before it answers. We use Claude's API, the version developers build on, so an answer in the Claude app on your phone can differ. These answers were asked the week of Nov 9, 2026.
We show what Claude said, word for word, and count who it named. Besides the question, we ask Claude only to check current information and to list the businesses it named at the end of its answer, which is how we count them. We don't rank anyone ourselves, nobody pays to appear, and our own clients get no special treatment: if a competitor of theirs is named, it's on the list.
AI answers can be wrong. Claude can name a business that has closed or misdescribe one, and we haven't checked each name. Treat this as a record of what Claude says, not a recommendation from Kalydron.
Spot an error about your business? Email hello@kalydron.com and a person will correct or remove it.
More AI Answers
Criminal defense lawyers in other cities
Los Angeles · Chicago · Houston · Dallas · Phoenix · Philadelphia · San Antonio · San Diego · Austin · Miami · Atlanta · Seattle · Denver · Boston · Las Vegas · Nashville · Charlotte · Orlando · San Francisco
Other services in New York City
Med spas · TMS clinics · Personal injury lawyers · Therapists · Concierge doctors